Lumpkin Family Foundation

Evaluating the Impact of 25 Years of Food System Grantmaking in East Central Illinois

Food Works Group (FWG) assessed 25 years of grants and initiatives for the Lumpkin Family Foundation (LFF) across East Central Illinois and Chicago. The goal was to evaluate LFF's role and the impact of its grantmaking on both the City of Mattoon and the broader East Central Illinois region. FWG also measured the growth trajectory of long-term grantees alongside LFF's investments and provided actionable insights to inform future grantmaking strategies. FWG surveyed grantees, interviewed grantees, staff, trustees, and community members, and analyzed decades of grantee data. The evaluation documented results across LFF's four program pillars. FWG built an interactive map, dashboards, and visualizations of LFF's portfolio, and designed a tiered evaluation framework that scales reporting to grant size so smaller grantees report less. The final report recommended moving toward multi-year unrestricted funding, along with an 18-month roadmap to put the new framework in place. (2025–2026)

Previous
Previous

University of New Hampshire